My baby girl was born with such a full head of hair that the nurses even gathered it into a tiny ponytail. But then my mother-in-law began insisting that I have it all cut off immediately.

“Put her in the yellow ducks,” I whispered, leaning back against the headboard while he carefully fastened the snaps.

When he finished dressing her, he pulled the wooden desk chair up beside the bed and sat down with his elbows resting on his knees. “How old was your sister, Gavin?” I asked quietly, keeping my eyes fixed on the tiny yellow ducks across our daughter’s chest.

He looked down at the sleeper he had just buttoned and let out a quiet sigh. “She was five years old, Nora.”

Before I could ask another question, Hazel turned her head and started rooting hungrily against the sleeve of his flannel shirt. I reached out and took her back into my arms, while Gavin stood up to go downstairs and fetch me a tall glass of cold water so I could finish feeding our daughter in peace.

That evening, after the house grew dark and quiet, I heard Gavin downstairs in the kitchen speaking to someone on his phone. Hazel had finally fallen asleep against my shoulder, and I was about to walk down to ask him to bring up whatever he had made for dinner.

I had told him earlier that I would happily eat anything he threw together, and from the faint smoky smell drifting up the stairwell, it seemed he had burned a batch of toast twice before getting it right. I stopped with one hand resting on the wooden banister when I heard his voice drop to an urgent whisper.

“She has not seen it yet, Mom, so please just lower your voice,” Gavin murmured from the bottom of the stairs.

I stood completely still in the dim hallway, holding my breath so I would not wake the baby against my chest. “Mom, I know what you said happened the last time, and I am taking care of things here,” he continued as his socked foot brushed against the bottom step.

He started walking up the staircase just as I stepped out from the shadows of the landing into the hall light. He saw me standing there and froze mid-step, and for several long seconds neither of us spoke a single word.

His mother’s sharp, anxious voice carried clearly through the speaker of the phone clutched against his thigh. “Gavin, did you check the back of the baby’s head like I told you to?”

Hazel stirred in her sleep and turned her warm face deeper into the soft fabric of my shirt. Slowly, keeping my eyes locked on Gavin’s pale face, I reached behind Hazel’s neck and parted her thick dark hair with two fingers.

“Nora, wait, let me explain first!” Gavin cried out, missing a step in his hurry and catching himself hard against the wooden banister.

PART 2

Just above the nape of Hazel’s hairline, hidden beneath the dark curls, was a flat pink birthmark no wider than my smallest fingernail. Two smooth, rounded edges met at a sharp little point at the bottom, making it look exactly like a tiny heart somebody had drawn lightly in pink pencil.

I let her dark hair fall back over her neck, then parted the strands a second time just to make sure my tired eyes were not playing tricks on me. “Is this what you meant when you told your mother I had not seen it yet?” I asked quietly.

Gavin nodded slowly while Brenda continued calling his name repeatedly through the phone speaker in his hand. He raised the phone to his ear, told his mother firmly that he would call her back later, and sat down heavily on the top step of the staircase.

“I saw a little flash of pink right there at the hospital, Nora, right after the nurse handed her back to you,” he confessed, staring down at the carpeted stair beneath his feet.

“Why on earth did you not say anything to me then?” I asked, keeping one hand gently supporting Hazel’s head.

“Because I already knew what it might look like once her hair dried,” he muttered, gripping the wooden spindle of the banister until his knuckles turned white. “My sister Daisy had one in the exact same spot.”

I stood in the hallway absorbing the sound of her name, realizing I had never once heard him speak it aloud during all our years together. “Daisy,” I repeated softly before walking quietly into the bedroom to lay Hazel down inside her bassinet.

Unpacking our hospital bags earlier that afternoon, I had left the nurse’s soft fabric hair tie sitting right beside the bottle of hand lotion on the dresser. Above it, the two bare metal hooks made the bedroom wall look stark and unfinished in the lamplight.

Gavin walked into the bedroom holding his phone and sat beside me on the edge of the bed, swiping back through years of saved photos past old Christmases and family vacations. Finally, a scanned photograph filled his bright screen, showing a younger woman sitting in a wooden chair with a baby resting across her knees.

The woman’s face was mostly cropped out of the frame, yet I immediately recognized Brenda by the familiar shape of her hands and her silver wedding band. She was gently holding the baby’s dark hair up with her fingertips, revealing a flat pink heart-shaped mark right above the infant’s hairline.

“I took a picture of that page from her baby book years ago when Mom let me look through it once,” Gavin said quietly as I reached over and swiped to the next image on his screen.

The following photograph was a picture of a scrapbook page dated five years later, showing Brenda sitting alone on a sofa while clutching a worn brown teddy bear. A clear plastic protective sleeve had been taped neatly beside her photograph, and inside that sleeve rested a single dark lock of child’s hair.

“When was this picture taken, Gavin?” I asked softly as the forgotten toaster popped downstairs in the empty kitchen, though neither of us moved to go down.

“Two weeks after Daisy died,” Gavin said, lowering his phone slightly into his lap.

“How old were you when it happened?” I asked, reaching out to rest my hand over his clenched fingers.

“I was seven years old, and I remember almost every detail of that morning,” he said, glancing briefly toward the empty hooks over our dresser. “Mom was planning to trim Daisy’s hair after breakfast, so she had set a tortoiseshell comb out on the dresser the night before.”

He told me how he had been sitting on the edge of his parents’ bed, tapping his sneaker heels against the wooden footboard while five-year-old Daisy stood on a low wooden stool in front of the mirror. Brenda had brushed through Daisy’s long hair while Daisy grinned happily at her own reflection in the glass.

“I climbed across the blankets to join them, and Mom crouched down behind the stool so all three of our faces could fit inside the mirror frame together,” Gavin said, his tightly clasped hands finally relaxing in his lap. “Mom just stood there smiling and watching Daisy admire herself, then said she would finish the actual haircut right after we ate breakfast.”

After they finished their pancakes, Daisy had climbed back onto the wooden stool by the dresser, and Brenda had barely picked up the scissors when a bright yellow butterfly fluttered past the open bedroom window. Daisy had jumped down from the stool laughing with delight and bolted out of the room toward the stairs.

“Mom called after her and followed right behind, but Daisy was fast for a five-year-old, and the front screen door had not latched properly that morning,” Gavin continued, his voice dropping to a hollow whisper. “Daisy pushed straight through the screen and chased that butterfly out across the front lawn into the street.”

Brenda had heard the screen door slap shut and sprinted down the porch steps after her, screaming her name, but Daisy had already stepped off the curb. A delivery driver slammed on his brakes as hard as he could, yet the truck could not stop in time on the wet pavement.

“Daisy passed away at the hospital that afternoon, and when we came home, that tortoiseshell comb was still sitting right where Mom had left it on the dresser,” Gavin said quietly. “For months afterward, if anyone moved that comb even an inch, she would put it right back in that exact same spot, and later she asked the funeral director for a lock of Daisy’s hair because it was the only part of that haircut she ever got.”

I looked up at my husband with tears stinging the corners of my eyes. “Did she always warn you about keeping babies away from mirrors after that?”

Gavin shook his head slowly and looked back toward the empty wall. “No, that rule came later, because she built an entire superstition around Daisy’s final morning to try to make sense of a senseless accident.”