“Really.”
She slipped her tiny hand into mine.
Willa took the other.
Together, we walked away from the Christmas lights.
The music faded.
The buildings grew older.
The streets became quieter.
Then Hazel suddenly stopped.
Her fingers tightened around mine.
“Mister?”
“Yes, sweetheart?”
“There’s something you should know about our mommy.”
I crouched beside her.
“What is it?”
She glanced nervously toward the dark alley.
Then leaned closer.
“Mommy doesn’t know we came here.”
My stomach tightened.
“Why not?”
Willa began crying.
Hazel hugged her sister.
Then looked straight into my eyes.
“Because Mommy told us not to tell anyone what happened last night.”
I stood frozen beneath the falling snow.
And suddenly, finding Santa was no longer the most important reason to follow those little girls home.
PART 2
The stairwell down to the basement smelled of damp concrete, rust, and old coal dust. A single bare bulb flickered over the yellowing walls.
I carried Willa, who had gone quiet against my shoulder. Hazel led the way past a row of dented utility meters until we reached a weathered green door with faded brass numbers: B-2.
Hazel tapped four times, a secret code.
“Mommy? It’s us. We brought a friend.”
Furniture scraped across concrete. Three deadbolts clicked open, one after another.
The door opened an inch.
A young woman stood in the sliver of light, no older than twenty-seven, in a faded gray sweater that hung off her thin frame. Her dark hair was twisted into a knot. Her eyes were hazel, exactly like her daughters’, and on her left temple sat a swollen purple bruise.
When she saw a tall stranger in a wool coat holding her child, the color drained from her face. She tried to slam the door.
“Please!” she gasped. “I told you I’d have the money by Monday! Don’t hurt my girls!”
I stopped the door with my boot and kept both hands open where she could see them.
“I’m not here to hurt anyone, ma’am. My name is Reed Sullivan. Your daughters found me at Rockefeller Center.”
She looked down at Hazel and Willa, who were smiling up at her.
“Hazel! Willa!” She pulled the door wide, gathered them into her arms, and shook as she held them. “I told you never to leave the building!”
“We went to tell Santa our address!” Willa said, patting her mother’s cheek. “And Mr. Reed walked us home!”
She looked at me with shock, embarrassment, and deep wariness, then stepped back and let me in.
The apartment was one room. Two narrow cots with thin blankets. A space heater humming in the corner. A fold-out table holding two half-empty cans of soup. No tree, no stockings, no decorations.
But it was spotless. The cots were made with careful corners, and a neat stack of library books sat beside the soup.
“I’m Josephine Hayes,” she said, touching her hair over the bruise. “Jo. I’m so sorry they bothered you.”
“They didn’t bother me.” I took a handkerchief from my pocket and held it out. “They did something I haven’t managed in two years. They made me stop walking in circles.”
Before she could answer, a fist slammed against the outer door.
BOOM. BOOM. BOOM.
“HAYES! OPEN UP! WE KNOW YOU’RE IN THERE! PAY UP OR WE TAKE THE GIRLS!”
Jo pulled her daughters behind her, her whole body shaking. “It’s the lenders from the waterfront. They said Monday. It isn’t even Monday.”
I took out my phone and called the one person I trusted to answer on Christmas Eve.
“Walter. I’m at a basement apartment on West 47th Street. Three men are trying to break in. Bring security, and call the police. Both.”
“Two blocks away, sir. Ninety seconds.”
I put the phone away and stepped between the door and the girls.
The frame splintered. A man with a crowbar shouldered inside, two others behind him. The first was heavyset, with bloodshot eyes and a grin that dropped when he saw me standing there.
“Who the hell are you?”
“Someone who’d like you to leave.”
“This is between us and her. She owes my boss eighty thousand dollars for her husband’s hospital bills.”
“I heard.”
He raised the crowbar. “Move.”
“No.”
Behind him, boots hit the stairs. Four members of my security team came through the door with flashlights, and behind them, two uniformed NYPD officers with their hands on their holsters.
“Drop it!” one of the officers shouted. “Hands where I can see them!”
The crowbar clattered to the concrete. The men were against the wall in under a minute, cuffed and cursing.