**Part 2**
ICU room 7.
The lights were dim. Machines beeping. An IV pole with three bags hanging from it.
He was lying in the bed with the head raised. A thin white blanket pulled up to his chest. An oxygen tube in his nose.
I almost didn’t recognize him.
The man I married had been big. Broad shoulders. Thick arms. A laugh you could hear across a bar.
The man in the bed was a skeleton. His cheeks were sunken. His arms were sticks. His skin was yellow. Deep yellow. Even the whites of his eyes were yellow. His stomach was swollen and round under the blanket.
His hair had gone completely white. His beard too.
He was fifty-three years old.
He looked eighty.
He was awake.
He turned his head when I came in.
He saw me.
And his face crumpled.
“Laura,” he whispered.
His voice was barely there.
“Hi, Greg.”
He looked past me. At Nathan in the doorway.
“Nate,” he said. “I told you not to make her.”
“He didn’t make me,” I said. “I wanted to come.”
Greg looked at me for a long time.
“You’re in your bathrobe,” he said.
I looked down. I’d forgotten.
“And slippers,” he said.
I laughed. I couldn’t help it. It came out wet and broken.
“I didn’t have time to change,” I said. “I’ve been up for thirty-six hours. Our son’s been missing.”
Greg closed his eyes.
“I’m sorry,” he said. “I’m so sorry, Laura. That’s my fault. I made him lie to you. All of it. My fault.”
I pulled a chair up to the side of the bed.
I sat down.
I didn’t know what to say. Ten years. I’d had ten years to think about what I’d say to Greg Rhodes if I ever saw him again. I’d practiced it in the shower. In the car. Lying awake at night.
I’d say, You ruined my life.
I’d say, Do you know what it did to Nathan, seeing you on that floor?
I’d say, I hope you’re happy. I hope it was worth it.
I didn’t say any of it.
I looked at him in that hospital bed. Yellow and wasted and dying. In a room with no flowers and no cards and no visitors except two sixteen-year-old boys covered in his blood.
“Three years sober,” I said finally. “Nathan told me.”
Greg opened his eyes.
“Three years, four months, and eleven days,” he said. “I counted this morning.”
“That’s good, Greg.”
“It’s too late,” he said. “But it’s good.”
He reached for the little table next to his bed. His hand was shaking so badly it took him three tries.
He picked up a plastic bag. A hospital belongings bag. The kind they put your clothes and wallet in when you’re admitted.
He handed it to me.
“Pocket,” he said. “Of the jacket. Nate’s wearing it. But I took it out before. It’s in the bag.”
I opened the bag.
There was a wallet. Old, cracked leather. A pair of reading glasses with one arm taped. A bronze coin. 3 YEARS. A recovery chip.
And an envelope.
Thick. Folded in half. Soft and worn at the edges like it had been carried for a long time.
On the front, in Greg’s handwriting, shaky and crooked:
For Laura. Only if she asks.
“What is this?” I asked.
“My ninth step,” Greg said.
I didn’t understand.
“AA,” he said. “The ninth step. Make amends to the people you hurt. Directly. Wherever possible.” He swallowed. “Except when to do so would injure them or others.”
He looked at me.
“I wrote that in 2022,” he said. “My first year sober. My sponsor said I should send it. I didn’t. I thought it would hurt you. I thought you’d built a good life. I didn’t want to tear it open.” He closed his eyes. “So I carried it. For three years. In the pocket of that jacket.”
I didn’t open it.
Not then.
I held it in my lap.
“Why didn’t you come back?” I asked. “When you got sober. Why didn’t you call? Why didn’t you try to see Nathan?”
Greg was quiet for a long time.
“Because I didn’t deserve to,” he said. “I left my six-year-old on a curb outside his school. I made him think I was dead on the kitchen floor. I didn’t get to come back from that. Not after ten years. Not just because I finally stopped drinking.”
“That’s not your decision to make,” I said. “That was Nathan’s decision. He deserved to know his father was sober. He deserved to choose.”
Greg looked at me.
“Maybe,” he said. “But I was scared, Laura. I was so scared. Scared he’d hate me. Scared you’d hate me. Scared I’d go see him and he’d look at me the way he looked at me that day in the kitchen. And I’d pick up a bottle.” He shook his head. “So I stayed away. I told myself I was protecting him. I was protecting me.”
I knew that feeling.
I’d been doing the exact same thing for ten years.
“And then I got sick,” Greg said. “And I thought, okay. This is it. I’ll die alone in a motel and nobody will ever know. And that’s fair. That’s what I earned.”
He turned his head. Toward the doorway. Toward Nathan.
“And then my son walked out of a Speedway with two Slurpees,” he said.
His voice cracked down the middle.
“Ten years,” he said. “And there he was. Six foot one. My eyes. My hands. Your smile. Standing in a parking lot. And he looked at me like…” He couldn’t finish.
“Like what?” I asked quietly.
“Like I was still his dad,” Greg said.
Nathan came into the room.
He stood at the foot of the bed in the olive green jacket.
“You are still my dad,” he said.
Greg looked at him.
“You taught me how to change oil,” Nathan said. “And fix a carburetor. And play guitar. And poker. You taught me how to make a fishing lure out of a bottle cap. You told me about the war. About the guys you served with. About Sergeant Hollis.” He wiped his eyes with the sleeve of the jacket. “You told me you used to sing to me every night. Friends in Low Places. You said you were terrible.”
“I was terrible,” Greg said.
“You still are,” Nathan said. “You sang it to me in the motel. Two weeks ago. You were terrible.”
Greg laughed. It turned into a cough. A bad one. I reached for the cup of water on the table. I held the straw to his lips. He drank.
When he could breathe again, he looked at Nathan.
“I’m sorry, Nate,” he said. “For all of it. For the kitchen. For the curb. For ten years.”
“I know, Dad,” Nathan said. “You told me. Like a hundred times.”
“I’ll tell you a hundred more.”
“You don’t have a hundred more,” Nathan said quietly.
The room went very still.
Greg looked at his son for a long time.
“No,” he said. “I guess I don’t.”
Denise came to the doorway with Cole.
Cole had washed his hands in a hospital bathroom. They were red and raw. He was holding something. A little wooden car. Rough. Lopsided. Whittled out of a piece of pallet wood. The wheels were slightly crooked.
He walked over to the bed. He set it on the little table next to Greg.
“I brought Bumblebee,” Cole said. “So you’d have something in here. It’s kind of empty.”
Greg looked at the little car.
“I made that for you, kid,” he said. “You’re supposed to keep it.”
“I’ll get it back,” Cole said. “Later.”
Greg looked at him. He knew what later meant.
“Okay,” he said quietly.
Then he looked past Cole. At Denise.
“You’re Cole’s mom,” he said.
“Denise,” she said.
“Denise.” Greg tried to sit up a little. He couldn’t. “I’m sorry. For your son lying to you. For your weekends. For tonight. That’s on me. All of it. He’s a good kid. The best. He made me soup every Saturday. From scratch. He said his mom taught him.”
Denise put her hand over her mouth.
“He told me it was for a girlfriend,” she said.
“I’m the girlfriend,” Greg said.
Cole laughed. Through tears. Denise laughed too. She couldn’t help it.
They moved Greg to a hospice unit two days later. At the VA. On the fourth floor. A private room with a window that looked out at the trees turning orange and red.
He’d said he didn’t want to die in a hospice.
But when Nathan asked him, he said, “If you’ll be there, Nate. I’ll go anywhere.”
So he went.
I opened the envelope on the second night.
I was sitting in the chair by his bed. He was asleep. Nathan was asleep too, curled up on the little vinyl couch by the window with the olive green jacket over him like a blanket.
I opened the envelope very carefully.
Inside, there were four pages. Handwritten. On lined notebook paper.
And a cashier’s check.
Pay to the order of Nathan Rhodes. $8,412.00.
The letter started like this:
Laura,
I’m three hundred and sixty-five days sober today. My sponsor says I have to do my ninth step. Make amends. So here goes.
I’m not going to ask you to forgive me. I don’t want you to. I don’t deserve it. I’m just going to tell you the truth. You deserve the truth.
Then he told me the truth.
About Iraq. About what happened on a road outside Tikrit in 2005, two months before I met him. About the truck in front of his. About three men he’d eaten breakfast with that morning. About carrying pieces of them back to the base in his arms. About how he’d never told anybody, not even me, because if he said it out loud it would be real.
About the first drink he had when he got home. To make the pictures stop.
About the pills, after his back. How they made the pictures go completely black. How he’d never felt anything so good in his life. How he’d have traded anything for that black. Even me. Even Nathan.
About the day of the curb. How he’d taken the pills at noon and woken up on the kitchen floor at four-thirty with Nathan standing over him. How Nathan had been holding his little backpack. How he’d looked at Greg with a face Greg would see every single night for the next six years.
Is Daddy dead?
I heard him say that, Greg wrote. I was half-awake. I heard my six-year-old ask if I was dead. And I couldn’t move. I couldn’t even open my eyes. I couldn’t answer him.
That’s when I knew I’d lost both of you. And that I deserved to.
The last page was different.
Laura, I don’t expect you to answer this. I don’t expect you to tell Nate. I don’t expect anything.
But I’ve been saving money. Since I got sober. Twenty dollars a week from the auto parts store. Sometimes thirty. It’s not much. It’s eight thousand dollars and some change. It’s the only thing I’ve ever done right for him.
It’s for his college. Or a car. Or whatever he wants. Don’t tell him it’s from me if you don’t want to. Tell him it’s from a guy you used to know.
I used to sing to him. Every night. You remember. Friends in Low Places. I was terrible.
He used to put his hand on my face while I sang. On my cheek. Like he was feeling the song come out.
I think about that every day.
Thank you for raising him. Thank you for locking the door. You were right to lock it. You saved him. You saved him from me.
I’m sorry I was the thing you had to save him from.
— Greg
I sat in that chair in the dark with the letter in my lap.
I looked at Greg. Asleep. Yellow. Breathing slowly. His hand lying on top of the blanket.
I looked at Nathan on the couch. Curled up under the olive green jacket. Sixteen years old. Six foot one. Greg’s hands. My smile.
I thought about the night I changed the locks. The two hundred dollars. The black garbage bags on the porch.
I’d been so sure I was doing the right thing.
I was. I still believe that. I’d do it again. A man who leaves a six-year-old on a curb doesn’t get to come home.
But I’d never once thought about what was happening to him on the other side of that door.
I’d never once wondered if he was trying.
I reached over in the dark.
I took Greg’s hand.
It was so thin. Just bones under yellow skin. His wedding ring was gone. But there was a pale line on his finger where it used to be. Ten years later. Still there.
He opened his eyes.
“Laura?”
“I read your letter,” I said.
He was quiet for a long time.
“I’m sorry,” he said finally. “I shouldn’t have—”
“I forgive you,” I said.
He stopped.
He looked at me. His yellow eyes filled up.
“You don’t have to—”
“I know I don’t have to,” I said. “I’m doing it anyway. Not because you deserve it. Because I’m tired, Greg. I’ve been carrying you around for ten years. In the back of my mind. Every time Nathan asked about a father-son dinner and I said he had a headache. Every time I heard a siren and wondered if it was you. I’m tired of carrying it.”
He was crying now. Silently. Tears running down his yellow cheeks into his white beard.
“I locked the door,” I said. “I’d lock it again. I’m not sorry I locked it.”
“You shouldn’t be.”
“But I’m sorry I never once wondered what was on the other side of it,” I said. “I’m sorry I never asked if you were okay. I’m sorry you got sober and thought you couldn’t come home. I’m sorry you had to carry that letter in your pocket for three years.”
Greg squeezed my hand. Barely. He didn’t have the strength for more.
“You were right,” he whispered. “To lock it.”
“I know,” I said. “But I’m unlocking it now.”
He lived six more days.
Nathan didn’t go to school. I didn’t make him. Neither did Denise. Cole came every afternoon. He brought chicken soup in a thermos. From scratch.
Greg couldn’t eat it. Cole brought it anyway.
Nathan played the guitar. The cheap pawn shop one from the motel room. He sat on the end of the bed and played every chord his father taught him.
On the fourth day, he played Friends in Low Places.
He was terrible.
Greg laughed so hard the nurse came in to check on him.
On the fifth day, a man came.
Older. Sixty, maybe. Gray buzz cut. Leather jacket. A screaming eagle pin on the lapel.
He stood in the doorway of the hospice room with his cap in his hands.
“Rhodes,” he said.
Greg opened his eyes.
“Hollis,” he whispered.
Sergeant Hollis. From Iraq. From Tennessee.
Nathan had found him. On Facebook. A 101st Airborne veterans group. He’d posted a picture of his dad’s jacket. The patch. The name tape.
Looking for anyone who served with Sgt. Gregory Rhodes, 2004–2006. He’s in hospice in Lexington. He doesn’t have much time.
Hollis drove four hours from Clarksville.
He sat by the bed for three hours. He held Greg’s hand. They didn’t talk much. Greg couldn’t talk much anymore.
But when Hollis left, Greg was smiling.
He died on the sixth day.
A Thursday. In the afternoon. The sun was coming in the window, lighting up the orange leaves on the trees outside.
Nathan was holding one of his hands. I was holding the other.
Cole was sitting in the chair by the window with his knees pulled up to his chest. Denise was standing behind him with her hands on his shoulders.
Greg hadn’t spoken since the night before. His breathing had changed. Slow. Long gaps between breaths. The nurse said it wouldn’t be long.
Nathan leaned close to his father’s face.
“Dad,” he whispered. “I’m here. I’m right here.”
Greg didn’t open his eyes.
But his hand moved. Just a little. In Nathan’s.
Nathan started singing.
Quietly. Badly. Off-key. Just to his father.
“Blame it all on my roots…”
And as he sang, he reached up with his free hand.
And put it on his father’s cheek.
Like he was feeling the song come out.
Greg took one more breath.
A long one.
Then he didn’t take another.
Nathan kept singing. All the way to the end of the chorus. His voice breaking on every line.
Then he put his head down on his father’s chest and sobbed.
I put my arm around my son.
And I held him.
And across the room, by the window, Cole Carter, sixteen years old, covered his face with his hands. Denise held him while he cried.
